Thread:IRosefeather/@comment-35109290-20180712023610/@comment-5986522-20180718224402

I'm not sure if you understood a few things properly, since your statements are going in circles.

Information responding to the sources we could actually confirm to be official (such as Kano's age) have already been added to the articles, the other ages are being removed, so I don't see why you are bringing up the false information again - it is being taken care of.

"Shintaro's birthday was stated in the booklet, as well. Using his birthday + age, one could have tried "estimating" the others." this sentence contradicts the fact that I linked the scan of Shintaro's booklet page which you later acknowledge lacks the age. If Shintaro is canonly noted to be 18 elsewhere, then that source can be added instead.

I also said they have to come from "somewhere" - I did not say "somewhere inside the children record booklet", as that has already been long understood to lack ages.

No one is asking for any purchases to be made, especially not the Children Record Booklet (again, the info responding to that on ages has been removed. We don't need any further confirmation). We are merely asking for trustable sources that are beyond tumblr posts without any scans, and spectulations. That the listed ages are incorrect in the other artbook is and remains an assumption until there is an official statement about them being incorrect that can be cited. So save your money if that is what you are trying to back up through purchases.

---

"I would list further plot information here but it would mean spoiling the current manga route and the final novel, along with some other references." The point of wikis is to add updates on released media. It would not be spoiling to add that information if it is officially released. That's what spoiler tags are for.

---

We would like to keep any discussions regarding this wiki on the wiki, so I have to decline on private messaging.

I will close this thread for now, as nothing has changed about previous statements from what I see, and the issue has been resolved for the time being in my eyes (confirmed sources are being added, other ages removed, assumptions dismissed on base of wiki rules).